Mainframe Modernization: Options, Risks and How to Start

The mainframe that processes every payment, policy or billing run has worked reliably for decades. But the people who know its COBOL code best are retiring, every new digital product needs data from it, and each change takes months of careful testing. Leaving it alone feels safe. Replacing it feels risky. Most organizations are stuck in between.
Mainframe modernization is about finding a path out of that position, one that keeps what works and reduces the risk of standing still.
Quick answer: Mainframe modernization means updating how mainframe applications, data and operations work so they can support modern digital services, without putting core business processes at risk. Options range from modernizing on the mainframe itself, to connecting it with cloud through APIs and integration, to moving selected workloads to other platforms. Most enterprises use a mix, step by step, based on business value and risk. CMEx delivers mainframe modernization through its Hybrid Cloud Modernization practice.
Why do mainframes still matter?
Mainframes are built for very high volumes of transactions with strong reliability and security. That is why they still run core systems in banking, insurance, retail, government, telecom and other industries. The problem is rarely that the hardware cannot cope. It is that applications, skills and integration have not kept up with how the rest of the business now works.
Why are organizations modernizing now?
Skills are leaving. Kyndryl's 2025 State of Mainframe Modernization survey of 500 leaders found that 70% of organizations struggle to find people with the right mix of mainframe and modern skills.
Digital services need mainframe data. Mobile apps, partner platforms and AI all depend on data and functions locked inside core systems.
Change is slow. Large, tightly coupled code bases make every change risky and expensive to test.
Regulation is pushing. In the same survey, 94% of respondents said regulatory compliance strongly influences their modernization plans.
Legacy carries security risk. The US Government Accountability Office's 2025 review of critical federal legacy systems found that many of the most critical ones use outdated languages, and several run with known cybersecurity vulnerabilities or unsupported hardware and software.
What are the main mainframe modernization options?
There is no single right answer. The best option depends on each application's value, risk and how often it changes.
Modernize on the mainframe: keep applications on the platform but update tools, development practices, code and operations, for example with modern DevOps pipelines and current languages and runtimes.
Integrate with hybrid cloud: expose mainframe functions and data through APIs and event streams so new cloud and digital applications can use them safely.
Replatform: move applications to a different platform with limited code changes, often running on Linux or containers.
Refactor or rewrite: convert or rebuild applications in modern languages and architectures, usually one business function at a time.
Replace: swap a custom application for a commercial or software-as-a-service product where one fits.
Retire: switch off applications and code that are no longer needed, which often reduces scope more than expected.
Kyndryl's survey found that 80% of organizations changed their modernization strategy in the past year, with many moving away from all-or-nothing programs toward more flexible, step-by-step approaches.
What are the biggest risks, and how do you manage them?
Big-bang failure: trying to replace everything at once is the highest-risk path. Modernize in small, tested steps instead.
Hidden business rules: decades of logic live in the code, often undocumented. Analyze and document applications before changing them.
Data consistency: core data must stay accurate while systems change. Plan data synchronization and migration carefully.
Performance: moved workloads must still handle peak volumes, such as month-end or festive season transactions. Test at real scale.
Security and compliance: controls and audit evidence must be maintained throughout. Involve risk and compliance teams early.
Skills gaps: combine experienced mainframe staff with cloud and modern development skills, and capture knowledge before people retire.
How do you start a mainframe modernization program?
Inventory and analyze applications. Map programs, data, dependencies, interfaces and business functions, and capture knowledge from experienced staff.
Classify each application. Decide whether to keep, modernize on the mainframe, integrate, replatform, refactor, replace or retire, based on value and risk.
Expose core functions through APIs. Quick wins often come from making mainframe services available to new channels through managed APIs.
Modernize development practices. Bring source control, automated testing and secure CI/CD pipelines to mainframe development.
Pilot one business function. Choose a contained area to prove the approach, measure results and build confidence.
Modernize in waves. Move further functions in planned stages, keeping systems running in parallel where needed.
Run as part of a hybrid estate. Manage the mainframe alongside cloud platforms with shared monitoring, security and automation, as covered in our guide to hybrid cloud modernization.
How CMEx delivers mainframe modernization
CMEx's Hybrid Cloud Modernization practice includes mainframe modernization as a core capability, as part of a wider hybrid cloud approach.
In practice, that covers:
Mainframe modernization, from integration and API enablement to replatforming and gradual refactoring.
Middleware modernization, updating integration and application server layers around core systems.
Container platforms and cloud migration for workloads that move off the mainframe.
Multi-cloud operations and sovereign cloud for organizations with strict data control requirements.
Partner technologies from IBM and Red Hat, including Red Hat OpenShift as a common platform.
This connects with CMEx's Enterprise Integration and DevSecOps work, and with industries such as Banking & Financial Services, where core systems run critical, regulated processes.
Frequently asked questions
Do we have to move off the mainframe to modernize?
No. Many organizations modernize while keeping the mainframe, by updating tools, development practices and integration. Others move selected workloads elsewhere. The right choice depends on each application's value, risk and cost.
What is the lowest-risk way to start?
Exposing mainframe functions and data through APIs is often the lowest-risk first step. It lets new digital services use core systems without changing the core code, and builds a foundation for later changes.
How long does mainframe modernization take?
Quick wins such as API enablement can be delivered in months. Modernizing a large portfolio usually takes several years, done in planned waves rather than one large project.
What happens to COBOL code?
It depends on the application. Some code stays in place and is maintained with modern tools, some is converted to other languages, and some is replaced or retired. Understanding and documenting the business rules in the code is essential before any change.
How do we deal with the mainframe skills shortage?
Capture knowledge from experienced staff through documentation and pairing, train newer developers using modern tools, and work with partners who bring both mainframe and cloud skills.
Can AI help with mainframe modernization?
Yes. AI tools can help analyze and explain old code, document business rules, suggest conversions and generate tests. Their output still needs expert review, especially for critical financial and regulatory logic.
How do we keep the business running during modernization?
Modernize in small steps, run old and new systems in parallel where needed, test at real volumes, and keep clear rollback plans. Avoid large, all-at-once cutovers for critical systems.
Conclusion
Mainframes still run many of the most important processes in large enterprises. Modernizing them is less about replacing a machine and more about making core systems easier to change, connect, secure and support. The safest path is step by step: understand your applications, open core functions through APIs, modernize development practices, prove the approach with a pilot and move in planned waves.
Planning the future of your core systems? A CMEx practice principal, not a sales rep, will review your mainframe estate and show which modernization path fits each part of it.


